Pearly Gates Cheese Board

I discovered The Pearly Gates on a whim at a friend's wedding reception where the dessert table had been reimagined as something ethereal and strange. The caterer had arranged white peaches, clouds of meringue, and softened brie on a marble board with silver leaf catching the afternoon light like actual gates to somewhere divine. I stood there with my plate thinking this wasn't supposed to work—fruit, cheese, and candy together—but it did, and I couldn't stop thinking about that combination for weeks after.

I made this for my partner's birthday dinner last summer, and what stuck with me wasn't the eating but the moment before serving when I held the tweezers over those meringues, carefully pressing tiny flakes of silver leaf onto their peaks. There's something almost meditative about that kind of deliberate finishing touch, knowing it serves no purpose except to make something already beautiful feel impossibly precious.

Ingredients

• Brie cheese, 250 g (9 oz): Keep it chilled right until serving because warm brie collapses and loses its velvety texture, but not so cold that it's rock hard and won't yield to a knife.
• White peaches, 3 ripe ones, sliced thin: The ripeness matters tremendously here—they should yield slightly to pressure but not be mealy, and slicing them thinly shows off their delicate color.
• Meringue kisses or nests, 12 small: Homemade is lovely but store-bought saves you an hour and honestly tastes nearly identical if you buy the good kind.
• Edible silver leaf, for decoration: It's pure visual drama with zero flavor, but it transforms this from pretty to actually show-stopping.
• White grapes, 1 small handful (optional): They add a clean, sweet contrast and their round shape echoes the meringue mounds.
• Blanched almonds, 1 small bowl raw or lightly toasted (optional): Toasting them brings out their subtle sweetness and gives you a gentle crunch that plays against the soft textures.

Instructions

Make the meringue if you're feeling ambitious:

Preheat your oven to 90°C (200°F) and beat 2 large egg whites with 100 g superfine sugar and a quarter teaspoon of cream of tartar until you get stiff peaks that hold their shape. Pipe or spoon small mounds onto a parchment-lined baking tray and let them bake low and slow for an hour until they're completely crisp all the way through, then cool them completely before touching them.

Arrange the brie thoughtfully:

Place your chilled brie wheel or wedge slightly off-center on your serving board, giving it room to breathe and leaving space for the other elements to have their moment.

Fan the peaches like you mean it:

Arrange your thinly sliced white peach slices in overlapping arcs around the brie, letting them catch light and showing off their pale blush color.

Cluster the meringue pieces:

Group your meringues in small clusters rather than scattering them randomly, which creates visual rhythm and makes guests understand they're meant to eat these things together.

Add the optional touches:

Scatter white grapes and almonds into the remaining gaps if you're using them, creating little pockets of different textures and sweetness levels.

Apply the silver leaf with intention:

Using tweezers, press tiny flakes of edible silver leaf onto some of the meringues and peach slices, being gentle because this stuff is gossamer-thin and bruises easily. It only takes a few scattered pieces to create that luminous, celebratory effect.

Serve right away:

Bring this to the table while everything is at its proper temperature and the silver leaf is still catching the light exactly right.

Save to Pinterest

What I didn't expect was that someone would ask for the recipe, and then someone else would, and now it's become this thing I make for occasions that feel like they need a little more elegance. It's taught me that fancy doesn't have to mean complicated, and sometimes the simplest combinations feel the most special.

The White Color Story

There's something psychological about a completely monochromatic board—it signals intention and thoughtfulness in a way a mixed board never quite does. The creamy whites and pale silvers and soft blush of the peaches create this almost soothing effect, like you've decided to celebrate without chaos, which honestly feels kind of revolutionary at a dinner party.

Building Your Own Version

You don't have to stick rigidly to this formula. I've made it with white nectarines when peaches weren't in season, and once I added white chocolate shards because someone in the group didn't eat fruit. The structure stays the same—creamy, sweet, crispy, and something that catches light—but the ingredients can shift based on what you find and who you're feeding.

Timing and Presentation Tips

This is the kind of dish that rewards a little theater in the serving. Assemble it just before people arrive so everything is at perfect temperature and the silver leaf hasn't started to dull. Explain what it is if you want, but honestly, let people discover the combination themselves—there's something delightful about watching someone try brie with meringue and peach for the first time.

• If you're making meringue ahead, bake it the morning of but add the silver leaf no more than an hour before serving.
• Slice your peaches just before assembly so they don't oxidize and turn brown, which would ruin the whole aesthetic.
• Have small plates and forks ready because this is definitely a composed-bite kind of situation, not something people will eat with their hands.

Save to Pinterest

The Pearly Gates taught me that sometimes a cheese board can be more than just a cheese board—it can be an actual moment. Serve this when you want people to feel celebrated.

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of cheese is best for this board?

Brie cheese, chilled for optimal texture, creates a creamy base that pairs beautifully with the fruit and meringue components.

→ Can I use store-bought meringue instead of homemade?

Yes, high-quality store-bought meringue works well as a shortcut without compromising texture or taste.

→ How should I prepare the peaches?

Thinly slice ripe white peaches to fan them around the cheese, enhancing both visual appeal and bite-sized ease.

→ What is the purpose of edible silver leaf here?

The silver leaf adds a celebratory, luxurious touch, delicately applied to meringue and peaches for an elegant presentation.

→ Are there suitable alternatives for a vegan version?

Yes, plant-based brie and aquafaba meringues can be used to adapt this board for vegan preferences.

→ How can I serve this cheese board for best flavor?

Serve slightly chilled and allow guests to mix flavors and textures for an interactive tasting experience.